Cuba Politics News and Information


Philip Peters: Raul Castro is changing Cuba - opinion


Published: Sat October 20, 2007
By: Publisher in Cuba Politics > Castro's Cuba
Tools: Tell-a-Friend | Email this author | Printer Friendly | Del.icio.us This


See your Cuba related advertisement here

UnionLeader.com

By PHILIP PETERS

When Fidel Castro fell ill in 2006, Washington thought change was at hand.

Secretary of State Condi Rice urged Cubans “to work at home for positive change,” and President Bush said Cubans were engaged in an “effort to build a transitional government.”

That did not happen. If anything, Cuba’s year without Fidel has been uneventful: no migration crisis, no attempt by Cuba’s dissidents to seize the moment, and 11 percent economic growth, according to the CIA.

But change may be in the offing, although not of the kind President Bush envisioned.

Cuba today is embroiled in a nationwide economic policy debate. It started in November 2005 when Fidel Castro gave his last major policy speech. “This revolution can destroy itself,” Castro worried, “and the fault would be ours.” He described an economy plagued by black-market activity, from pilfered inventories to off-the-books entrepreneurship.

Castro’s solution was more policing and more state control. He threatened to close Cuba’s remaining private restaurants and to give a “Christian burial” to private taxis that save Cubans from scarce public transit. He planned to deploy teenage “social workers,” who were already watching the till in gas stations, to combat corruption in bakeries, pharmacies, and cafeterias.

But then Castro left the political stage for the first time since 1959.

His brother Raul took over and soon made the economy his priority too. He declared that he is “tired of excuses.” He settled debts to farmers and tripled prices paid to milk and beef producers. He eased customs rules to allow Cubans to receive more aid from relatives overseas. Rather than “bury” private taxis, he ordered police to stop harassing them. Private restaurants remain open. Fidel’s social workers returned to their normal jobs.

And under Raul Castro, the economic debate took a very different turn.

Articles in the state-controlled media showed that many state enterprises are dysfunctional and have no supply system.

Discussion of the black market continues, but in Fidel’s absence, no one is scapegoating “egotists” and “cheapskates” who skirt the law. Raul Castro recognized that many Cubans resort to “indiscipline” because they are underpaid. There’s a big difference between blaming greed, and saying people deserve a day’s pay for a day’s work.

On July 26, Raul Castro gave his first major policy speech. He told folksy stories to highlight red tape and low productivity in state agriculture. He called for “structural changes and changes of concepts.” He quoted Fidel, seven years ago: “Revolution is a sense of the historical moment, it is to change all that must be changed.”

Before the speech, the Communist Party and institutions across Cuba were told to identify roadblocks to higher output, productivity and living standards. Today the speech is being debated in workplaces, union locals, and neighborhood party cells.

This debate is yielding ideas that were taboo one year ago: expand private agriculture and small enterprise, provide micro-credits, get the state out of services it provides poorly, grant autonomy to state enterprises, expand foreign investment.

Having unleashed this debate, Raul Castro has yet to make major decisions. But he has raised public expectations so high that he has obliged himself to deliver results. After all, he could be singing the old refrain that a besieged Cuba must concentrate on defense and cannot experiment in domestic policy. But his message is the exact opposite.

Meanwhile, President Bush now focuses on the day when “the good Lord will take Fidel Castro away” as a moment for Washington to seize. But that train has left the station. Cubans have assimilated Fidel Castro’s absence, a leadership succession has been accomplished, and Raul Castro is governing.

With real prospects of change looming in Cuba, the administration continues to shun the people-to-people and diplomatic contacts that could increase America’s influence there.

Raul Castro may prefer it that way, but it is no way to serve our national interests at a turning point in our neighbors’ history.

Philip Peters is vice president of the Lexington Institute in Arlington, Virginia and author of the blog, The Cuban Triangle.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

CONTACT US with news tips, press releases, announcements, travel notes, etc

Comments

#1 - On Sat October 20, 2007, Publisher (posts: 2782) wrote:

I may sound like a broken record but there is still noting in here to change my belief that there will be chaos after the announcement of Fidel’s death.

Raul may have encouraged discussion and one of three things will happen…

1. He will declare and end to the discussions and tell the Cuban people they must now work harder

2. The Cuban people will want REAL change like the ability to work for themselves and speak freely and thus force Raul to make sweeping reforms (which he then will not be able to control).

3. Same shit different day. How long will people simply “discuss” change without the ability to act on it.

In my opinion Raul is just is just buying time and NOT leading his country.  He is not a leader, he is a manager. He’s a great manager but a leader of a country? No.


Signature:

This is my signature - get yours in Your Control Panel. Go ahead and add a link to your site. Self promotion is permitted as long as it is beneficial to our community.

#2 - On Sat October 20, 2007, J. Perez wrote:

I respectfully disagree, we have had a leader for the last 48 years with the emphasis being on ideology. What we need now is a manager who can manage whatever reforms are instituted, they must be practical reforms that can benefit the average citizen and give hope to the young and I believe Raul will put them in place. They won’t be sweeping but the’ll get the ball rolling.

From our side here in the U.S., nothing will happen until this mindless crowd is out of office.

I believe Mr. Peters is right on the money.


#3 - On Sat October 27, 2007, MiamiCuban wrote:

I too think Mr. Peters has it right.  In listening to Bush’s speech the other day, I realized just how clueless he is with respect to Cuba’s reality.  My impression, from my last visit to Cuba, is that Cubans in general are well educated and have embraced Fidel’s ideologies, but they’re also not blind to the fact that certain changes need to be made if they want economic reform.  I believe change will come through and by the people in the form of active participation, but without losing what they’ve gained over the years.  This of course is what infuriates the Miami congresspeople and other powerplayers in Miami.  They don’t want “freedom” for Cuba as they always claim.  What they want is a capitalist Cuba their way, and they’re now seeing it won’t happen.  It’s not Fidel who stands in their way, but the Cuban people themselves.


Submit A Comment / Login

Name:

Email: (Required. For Havana Journal use only. Not displayed to public.)

URL:

Notify me of follow-up comments?

 Please enter the word/numbers you see in the image above:

View all Havana Journal politics articles in 2008

Cuba Marketplace


BUY CUBAN CIGARS

Havana.biz for Cuba consulting, domains and websites in development


Your graphic ad above
--- $500 per month ---

Images of Cuba


Big red American classic car in Cuba
La aroma de Cuba cigar box label
Cuban troops on the way to battle

Write Here


CONTACT US with news tips, press releases, announcements, travel notes, requests for information, etc.

Write your own article

Section Archive

RSS Subscriptions


Miscellaneous


Links to Site



Join the Cuba Chamber of Commerce

Cuba Chamber of Commerce -- Founding Member

Please note that US citizens are restricted by US laws that prohibit the purchase of any products made in Cuba. US citizens are also restricted by law to spend any money in Cuba. HavanaJournal.com is a Cuba information resource and does not endorse sales of Cuban products to US citizens.