Havana Cuba Business Travel Culture and Politics

Havana Cuba News

Cuba Business News

Posted October 24, 2008 by publisher in Cuba-World Trade

Email this article | Print this article | Search Havana Journal        

(Original title: How Cuba’s oil could change the US Embargo. Sorry, thought mine was better grin

By Tim Padgett | Time.com

For decades, the only promise most Cubans saw in the ocean north of their island was the current that carries homemade rafts to Florida. That all changed a few years ago when geologists estimated that between 5 billion bbl. and 10 billion bbl. of oil lie beneath the waters off Cuba’s northwest coast. Suddenly it seemed as though the hemisphere’s sole communist nation might finally end its desperate dependence on oil-rich allies like the former Soviet Union and Venezuela — and perhaps even escape its impoverished economic time warp altogether.

Washington’s own Cuba time warp got a jolt as well. The oil discovery has renewed debate over whether a crude-thirsty U.S. should loosen its 46-year-old trade embargo against Cuba and let yanqui firms join the drilling, which is taking place fewer than 100 miles off U.S. shores. Despite the Bush Administration’s hard line on Cuba, Republicans in Congress have proposed legislation to exempt Big Oil from the embargo. That clamor is sure to rise — especially if Barack Obama, who is more open to dialogue with Havana, becomes the next President — now that Cuba’s state oil company, Cubapetroleo, or Cupet, has announced a stunning new estimate of more than 20 billion bbl. bubbling off its shores. “This is not a game,” Cupet’s exploration manager, Rafael Tenreyro, assured reporters in Havana last week.

If true, those potential reserves could make Cuba a major petro player in the hemisphere. (The U.S. has reserves of 29 billion bbl.) And it could render the embargo an even more ineffective means of dislodging the aging Castro brothers, Fidel and current President Raúl. “If it really is 20 billion, then it’s a game changer,” says Jonathan Benjamin-Alvarado, a Cuba oil analyst at the University of Nebraska-Omaha. “It provides a lot more justification for changing elements of the embargo, just as we did when we allowed agricultural and medical sales to Cuba” a decade ago.

But is the Cuban calculation really on the level? Skeptics ask if the 20-billion-bbl. estimate is just a ploy to rekindle investor interest, at a time when falling oil prices could make the maritime find less attractive to the potential international partners Cuba needs to extract the oil. The effort is all the more urgent, they add, because reduced oil revenues could also make friends like left-wing Venezuelan President Hugo Chávez less able to aid Cuba with cut-rate crude shipments and capital to improve the island’s aged refineries. “The Cuba numbers from my point of view are not valid,” says Jorge Pinon, an energy fellow at the University of Miami and an expert on Cuba’s oil business. “I think they’re feeling a lot of pressure right now to accelerate the development of their own oil resources.” Benjamin-Alvarado gives Cuba’s geologists more benefit of the doubt; but he calls the 20-billion-bbl. estimate “off the charts.” “I trust them as oil people, and their seismic readings might be right,” he says, “but until we see secondary, outside analysis, this is going to be suspect.”

The U.S. Geological Survey (USGS), a government agency, made the initial estimate of 5 billion bbl.to 10 billion bbl. for Cuba’s northwest offshore sector (known as the Exclusive Economic Zone, or EEZ) in 2004. Tenreyro says Cupet’s analysis is based on what he calls a more accurate comparison of similar maritime oil fields like those off Mexico’s Gulf Coast. “We’re talking about that magnitude,” he argued last week. “We have more data” than the USGS. But Cupet, an arm of Cuba’s ultra-secret communist government, hasn’t offered much more evidence than that. Chris Schenk, who as USGS coordinator in the Caribbean led the 2004 survey, agrees that Cuban geologists “are very good.” But he adds, “We would like to see more data.” Still, Schenk notes, because of the embargo and Havana’s insular information policies, “we can’t converse with the Cubans.”

The Spanish energy company Repsol-YPF has entered into a production-sharing agreement with Cupet and is scheduled to start drilling the first real well in the EEZ next year. Other international firms, including Norway’s StatoilHidro and India’s Oil & Natural Gas Corp., are part of the Repsol-led consortium. Venezuela’s state-run Petroleos de Venezuela is considered a lesser player because it has little deep-water drilling experience. (China is also interested but so far only involved in onshore drilling in Cuba.) Cuba is now in important negotiations with Brazil’s Petrobras, which just made its own multibillion-barrel oil find off its coast near Rio de Janeiro and could, analysts say, be the major offshore drilling partner for Cuba if it jumps in.

Still, the concessions so far represent less than a quarter of the 59 drilling blocks that Cuba hopes to exploit in the 43,000-sq.-mi. (112,000 sq km) EEZ. Analysts say one reason is the daunting infrastructural difficulties facing any company that drills in Cuba: firms have to bring much more of their own capital, equipment, technology and on-the-ground know-how than usual. This year’s severe hurricane damage in Cuba has made the situation worse. Canada’s Sherritt, in fact, recently dropped out of its four-block contract. “Who else is going to be willing to actually come in and take the risk in Cuba?” says Benjamin-Alvarado. “In terms of proximity and technology, the only people really able to do it to the extent the Cubans need are the Americans.”

Cuba now produces about 60,000 barrels of oil per day (BPD) and consumes more than 150,000 BPD. (It also produces natural gas.) Venezuela makes up the difference by shipping almost 100,000 BPD to Cuba. The University of Miami’s Pinon says the more serious issue is refining capacity: even if Cuba has only the low estimate of 5 billion bbl. — which could yield more than 300,000 BPD — it needs Venezuela’s investment to upgrade refineries like the Soviet-built plant at Cienfuegos. But plummeting crude prices mean that Chávez may have a lot less wealth to spread around for his petro-diplomacy projects. “Like the collapse of the Soviet Union,” says Pinon, “this kind of thing has always been Cuba’s Achilles’ heel.”

If Cuba really does have 20 billion bbl. to drill, however, it could more easily find other interested refinery investors, like Brazil. The question is whether the U.S. will want to step off the sidelines and get a piece of the action too. Kirby Jones, head of the U.S.-Cuba Trade Association and an embargo opponent, says Tenreyro’s staff has been credible in the past, and he believes the new estimate is probably accurate. “So for the U.S., this becomes an 800-lb. guerrilla knocking on everybody’s door,” says Jones. “With that much oil, there would be the feeling that there’s a real [U.S.] price to be paid for [maintaining] the embargo. It changes Cuba’s economic situation drastically and makes the U.S. less relevant.”

Perhaps, but in the short run it’s more likely to make the U.S. more determined to do its own offshore drilling. Vice President Dick Cheney and other Bush Administration officials point to Cuba’s petro fortunes as justification for opening more of America’s coastline to oil production. Recent polls in U.S. coastal states like Florida support that idea, despite environmentalist complaints that both U.S. and Cuban offshore rigs will foul the Gulf of Mexico. Meanwhile, embargo proponents on Capitol Hill have sponsored bills that would, among other sanctions, deny visas to the executives of foreign oil companies that drill oil in Cuba. Their reasoning: the more oil wealth Havana gains, the less incentive it has to pursue democratic reform.

That last part may well be true. But at the end of the day, U.S.-Cuba relations continue to exist in a Cold War time warp. As a result, in both Washington and Havana, 20 billion bbl. of oil might not be such a game changer after all.

— With reporting by Dolly Mascarenas / Mexico City

—————————————————Havana Journal Comments————————————————

Havana Journal Inc. owns CubanOil.com and is always looking for development partners.

Find Cuba on Amazon

  1. Follow up post #1 added on October 24, 2008 by publisher with 3905 total posts

    Then there is this story by Jeff Franks titled Cuba oil claims raise eyebrows in energy world.

    Cuba’s announcement last week that its still untapped offshore oil fields may hold more than 20 billion barrels of oil has raised eyebrows among outside oil experts who say the big number is hard to believe but not out of the realm of possibility.

    They said Cuba has excellent geologists, but they would like to see the findings verified by independent experts who have no stake in the Caribbean island’s oil future.

    Cuba consulting services

  2. Follow up post #2 added on October 25, 2008 by Asoka Kuruppu

    It seems ok   for US oil executives to work in undemocratic Middle East but not Cuba !
    Grow up USA.

  3. Follow up post #3 added on October 27, 2008 by Cubana with 282 total posts

    Even this article uses words that would lead the reader to the conclusion that Cuba had made an oil discovery. This is TOTALLY INCORRECT. All Cuba has done is estimate on the basis of similar geology to US and Mexican oilfields in the Gulf of Mexico that there MAY be oil in its sector. Previous wells drilled by Spanish companies have been dry or uncommercial and even today, with the big advances in 3-D siesmic technology one in three wells drilled fall into this category.

  4. Follow up post #4 added on October 27, 2008 by publisher with 3905 total posts


    Great summary. This story has gotten legs and the 20 billion barrel number is taken for granted but we all know we can’t trust any numbers or statistics that come out of Cuba.

    Cuba consulting services

  5. Follow up post #5 added on October 30, 2008 by publisher with 3905 total posts

    Brazilian President Lula da Silva signed an agreement that would allow Brazil to produce oil in Cuba.

    Brazil’s state-run oil company, Petrobras, will drill for deep-water exploration of oil.

    Cuba consulting services

  6. Follow up post #6 added on October 31, 2008 by Asoka Kuruppu

    Viva Lula !

Would you like to add more information?

Only members can add more information. Please register or log in

  • Advertise at Havana Journal Inc
We recommend this AirBnB Food and Drink Experience... Cuban flavors: Food, Rum and Cigars
Images of Cuba
Mirrors - Cuban art - Painting by Wifredo Lam
Follow Havana Journal
SUBSCRIBE to our Cuba Watch newsletter
LIKE us on Facebook

FOLLOW us on Twitter

CONNECT with us on Linked In

Section Archive
Havana Journal, Inc. BBB Business Review

Member of the Association for the Study of the Cuban Economy